20/09/2007 00:00:00
UK: Fewer than 1 in 8 recorded crimes end up in court
---
Criminals responsible for almost four million crimes reported to the
police last year escaped any punishment by the courts, it has emerged.
Home Office research revealed that - of 5.4 million crimes logged by
officers - only one in every eight ended with a criminal charge or
summons being made.
In a shocking 3,953,000 cases, the equivalent of 73 per cent of all
recorded crimes, the offender was simply not caught.
But, even when police did manage to catch the culprit, fewer than half
were dragged before the courts or received a formal charge.
Instead, they escaped with a caution, on-the-spot fine, warning for
smoking cannabis or had their crime 'taken into consideration' alongside
other offences.
Of all the crimes reported last year, only 693,821 were punished using
the traditional route of a criminal charge and appearance before a
magistrate or judge.
Experts and Opposition MPs last night warned it was yet more proof of
the lurch towards "soft justice".
Overall, the "detection" rate for recorded crimes remained stable last
year, at 27 per cent.
But this only achieved thanks to a huge increase in the number of minor
offences, such as drunkenness, which were punished by fixed -penalty
notices.
Along with warnings for cannabis, these £80 on-the-spot fines now
represent 15 per cent of all crimes police claim to have solved.
Meanwhile, the number of crimes investigated by police which led to
someone being charged or summonsed fell by more than 31,000 last year,
to around 694,000, or 47 per cent of all crimes punished.
Even then, there is no guarantee the offender was punished, as it
includes cases later dropped by the CPS for lack of evidence or other
problems.
At the same time, the proportion of crimes dealt with by a caution rose
by 15 per cent last year to 357,300, and the number punished with an
on-the-spot fine jumped by almost a third to 139,735.
Of the 531,450 violent crimes detected by police, the number dealt with
by a caution rose to 29 per cent.
Cannabis warnings - which do not even carry a criminal record - rose by
28 per cent to more than 81,000.
Shadow Home Secretary David Davis said: "The Government fiddle the
figures on crime at every opportunity, trying to boost the impression of
action on crime by encouraging cautions and fixed penalty notices at the
expense of real prosecutions.
"Even despite those efforts, the latest figures show that just one in
four crimes are detected. Just as disturbing, at a time of heightened
concern, nearly a third of violent crimes are now let off with just a
warning."
Detecting crimes is a crucial measure of police success, with ministers
telling the police they must increase the number of "offenders brought
to justice" each year.
But the target pays no attention to the types of crime being solved-
with handing out an on-the-spot fine carrying the same importance as
catching a sex attacker.
The report revealed that - for many of the crimes the public fears most
- the detection rate is appallingly low.
For burglary, it is only 14 per cent, robbery 18 per cent, sex offences
30 per cent and criminal damage 13 per cent.
David Green, director of the Civitas think-tank, said: "The Government
is distorting the measures of police activity to give an impression of
effectiveness.
"But what this shows is that, if you consider a criminal being taken to
court as a measure of effective action being taken, that is happening in
less than half of cases."
He added: "They are putting down detections for quite trivial things,
which means more serious crimes are being neglected."
Norman Brennan, director of the Victims of Crime Trust, said: "These
figures themselves are very worrying, because they show just how many
people or getting away with crime or not being detected.
"But they only represent the crimes which were reported to the police.
The true, number, I believe, is likely to be five-times higher - making
matters even worse.
"The criminal justice system is out of control, but nobody seems
prepared to admit it, or do anything about it."
Seven of the 43 police forces In England and Wales saw their detection
rates fall year-on-year. These were City of London and Wiltshire (both
down 5 per cent), Bedfordshire and Thames Valley (both down 3 per cent),
Cambridgeshire (down 2 per cent), and Derbyshire and Leicestershire
(both down 1 per cent.
Detection rates remain stubbornly low despite an enormous increase in
taxpayers cash being spent on the police.
Funding has increased by nearly £5 billion since 1997, from £6.2 billion
to £11 billion
Police Minister Tony McNulty said: "We have seen crime fall by a third
over the last decade and this is in large part thanks to the range of
powers available to the police to bring offenders swiftly to justice.
"The increase in the sanction detections rate is good news. It shows
that police are using efficient and effective methods to deal with lower
level offending leaving the courts to concentrate on the most serious cases.
"I will continue to work with the Police and my counterparts in the
Ministry of Justice to deliver the efficiency improvements that will
help officers spend more time where we all most want them to be: on duty
on the frontline."
http://www.thisislondon.co.uk/
Source:
http://www.ukcia.org/news/shownewsarticle.php?articleid=12853
Author:
Evening Standard via UKCIA
|